Comparative analysis of the ideas of Alexander, Heidegger and Gadamer about architecture

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 PhD, Faculty of Architecture and Urban Planning, Art University of Isfahan, Isfahan, Iran

2 Assistant Professor, Faculty of Architecture and Urban Planning, Iran University of Art, Tehran, Iran

3 Professor, Faculty of Architecture and Urban Planning, Iran University of Art, Tehran, Iran

Abstract

Christopher Alexander introduces an interpretation about the architecture in the chapter “Face of God” of “Nature of Order: The Luminous Ground “.On the other hand, philosophers of phenomenology such as Martin Heidegger and Hans-Georg Gadamer also have theories about the interpreting of art-works, including architecture, which seem to be comparable to Alexander's ideas in some respects. This research intends to do a comparative analysis of Alexander's ideas with Heidegger's and Gadamer's ideas about the architecture. This analysis will be done by emphasizing two key concepts of Heidegger's and Gadamer's theories, that is, the concept of uncertainty in interpretation of texts and in author's intention, and concept of the interpreter's mental preinterpretation and subjective knowledge. The research is qualitative and fundamental, and it was conducted using the phenomenological method with a phenomenological hermeneutic approach. The results of the research emphasize the existence of a relationship between Alexander’s interpretation about architecture and the architect's mentality and Heidegger's and Gadamer's ontological theories on art and architecture. The results of examining the concept of uncertainty have shown that there is a closeness between the opinions of these three theorists regarding the existence of a truth behind the artwork and its appearance through architectural works. The results of the investigation of the concept of uncertainty have shown that the meaning of art-works is not definite and fixed for the mentioned philosopher, and according to Alexander, the art-works has a fixed truth. The results of the study of the concept of the interpreter's mental preinterpretation in architecture have also shown that Alexander's thoughts about internal knowledge are related to the architect's mentality and the creation of architecture, and according to Heidegger and Gadamer, internal knowledge, prejudices, and mentality are related to the audience and observer of the architectural work. Also, similarities between the thoughts of these three theorists were seen in the belief in the realization of the principle of unity between the creator and the art-work, and the audience and the art-work.

Keywords

Main Subjects

References

Ahmadi, Babak. Structure and Hermeneutics. Tehran: Gam Nou, 2002. (In Persian)
________ . The Text Structure and Textural Interpretation. Tehran: Markaz, 2011. (In Persian)
Alexander, C. The Nature of Order, vol. 1: Phenomenon of Life, an Essay on the Art of Building and the Nature of the Universe. California: Berkeley university press, 2004.
________ . The Nature of Order, vol. 4: The Luminous Ground. California: Berkeley university press, 2003.
Arzhmand, Mahmoud. “Eligibility in Restoration”. Doctoral thesis in Restoration, Isfahan: Isfahan Art University, School of Conservation and Restoration, 2016. (In Persian)
Azad Aramaki, Taghi and H. Lajurdi. “Hermeneutics of Reconstruction or Dialogue”. Social Sciences Letter, no. 21 (Autumn 2003): 93-112. (In Persian)
Bagheri, SM., M. Arzhmand, and SB. Hosseini. “Study of How Humans Interpret Art Works (from Gadamer’s philosophical hermeneutics)”. Iranian Scientific Association of Visual Arts, electronic publication (winter 2022): 1-17. (In Persian)
Gadamer, H.G. Philosophical Hermeneutics. Translated by David E. Ling. California: University of California Press, 1977.
________ . The Relevance of the Beautiful and other Essays. Translated by N. Walker, Edited with Introduction by Robert Bernasconi. New York: Cambridge University Press, 1986.
Hajian, Kh. & Z. Davari Graghani. “The Existence of Philosophical Hermeneutics in Hafez’s Poetry, an Ontological Reflection”. Kohan Name-ye Adab-e Parsi, vol. 6, no. 1 (autumn 2015): 95-111. (In Persian)
Heidegger, Martin. The Beginning of Artistic Work. Translated by P. Ziashahabi. Tehran: Hermes, 2003. (In Persian)
________ . “Building, Being, Thinking”. in Modern Hermeneutics, Selection of Essays. Translated by B. Ahmadi and others. Tehran: Markaz, 2006. (In Persian)
________ . Building, Being, Thinking, Philosophy of Technology. Translated by Shapour Etemad. Tehran: Markaz, 2014. (In Persian)
Madani, A. “Examining What Is Hermeneutics”. Critical Studies in Texts and Programs of Human Sciences, vol. 12, no. 1 (spring and summer 2013): 85-96. (In Persian)
Malps, Jeff. Gadamer and His Aesthetics. Translated by Vahid Gholami Pourfard. Tehran: Ghoghnoos, 2015. (In Persian)
Marsh, David and Paul Furlong. “Ontology and Epistemology in Political Science”. Political Science, Vol. 13, No. 42 (Summer 2008): 31-63. (In Persian)
Mohajeri, Nahid and Shiva Qomi. “Analytical Approach to Design Theories of Christopher Alexander from Notes on Synthesis of Form and Pattern Language to New Concepts of Complexity Theory”. Hoviat-e Shahr, vol. 2, no. 2 (spring and summer 2008): 45-56. (In Persian)
Nadimi, Zoha. “A Research on the Nature of the Center and Its Role in the Enhancement of Architecture”. Master’s thesis in architecture, Yazd: Yazd University, School of Art and Architecture, 2011. (In Persian)
Palmer, Richard A. Hermeneutics: Theory of Interpretation in the Philosophies of Schleier Macher, Dilthey, Heidegger, Gadamer. Translated by M.S. Hanai Kashani. Tehran: Hermes, 2014. (In Persian)
Partovi, Parvin. Phenomenology of place. Tehran: Art Academy, 2008. (In Persian)
Rahbarnia, Z. and Amene Mafitabar. “Principles of Hermeneutic Phenomenology in the Interactive Arrangement ‘When Nothing Happens’ by Ernesto Neto”. Kimia-ye Honar, vol. 4, no. 15 (Summer 2015): 33-46. (In Persian)
Rahmani, M. and A. Nadernejad. “The Role of Feeling in Creating Architecture”. Sofe, vol. 23, no. 3 (2012): 7-18. (In Persian)
Ramin, Farah. “Art; The Only Way of Salvation (Looking at Heidegger’s Philosophy of Art and Its Relationship with the Thought of Muslim Thinkers)”. Mashregh-e mouood, vol. 6, no. 21 (Spring 2012): 5-26. (In Persian)
Razavi, SA. “Hermeneutics and Interpreting of Historical Knowledge”. Andishe-ye dini. no. 37 (Winter 2010): 103-146. (In Persian)
Razavi, SA. and SA. Shahrokhi. “Philosophical Hermeneutics and Epistemological Foundations of History”. Philosophy of Religion, vol. 7, no. 8 (Winter 2010): 65-92. (In Persian)
Rikhtegaran, M. The Logic and Topic of Hermeneutics: Principles and Foundations of the Science of Interpretation. Tehran: Ministry of Culture and Islamic Guidance, 2008. (In Persian)
Sarami, N., K. Mandgari, and Hadi Nadimi. “Origin of the Concept of ‘The Void’ in Christopher Alexander’s Thought”. Andishe-ye Memari, vol. 3, no. 6 (autumn and winter 2018): 29-43. (In Persian)
Shamisa, Cyrus. Literary Criticism. Tehran: Ferdous Publications, 2008. (In Persian)
Siros Sabri, Reza. and Ali Akbari. “The Concept of Order: Christopher Alexander and the New Science”. Sofe, vol. 23, no. 2 (Autumn 2013): 31-41. (In Persian)
Spiegelberg, Herbert. Phenomenological Movement. Translated by Masoud Olya. Tehran: Minue Kherad, 2013. (In Persian)
Tahuri, Nayer. “Learning from Heidegger: Phenomenology in Architecture, the Influence of Heidegger’s Philosophy in Architectural Theorizing: The Identity of Place in the Theories of Christian Norberg Schultz and Christopher Alexander”. Kimia-ye Honar, vol. 6, no. 25 (Winter 2016): 73-92. (In Persian)
Turan, Emdad. The Historicity of Interpreting in Gadamer’s Hermeneutics: An Inquiry into Truth and Method. Tehran: Basirat, 2009. (In Persian)
Vaezi, Asghar and Faeze Fazeli. “The Horizon of Interpreting in the Mirror of Interpreting the Horizon”. Philosophy, vol. 39, no. 2 (autumn and winter 2011): 59-85. (In Persian)
Weinsheimer, Joel. Philosophical Hermeneutics and Literary Theory: A Review of Gadamer’s Opinions in the Field of Hermeneutics. Translated by Masoud Olya. Tehran: Ghoghnoos, 2002. (In Persian)
Zafaranchi, Nasser. About Contemporary Hermeneutics in Contemporary Philosophical Approaches in the West. vol. 4. Tehran: Research Institute of Human Sciences and Cultural Studies, 2008. (In Persian)

Files

History

  • Receive Date: 02 February 2023
  • Revise Date: 28 December 2023
  • Accept Date: 10 March 2025

Share

How to cite

Statistics