Soffeh

Soffeh

Evaluation of the effect of kinematic axes and the geometric model of the kinetic facade on providing natural lighting in an office building in Tehran

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
1 Ph.D. in Architecture, Department of Architecture, ST.C, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran
2 Associate Professor of Architecture, Department of Architecture, ST.C, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran
3 Professor of Architecture, Department of Architecture and Urban Planning, Tehran University of Art, Tehran, Iran
4 Assistant Professor of Architecture, Department of Architecture and Urban Planning, Tehran University of Art, Tehran, Iran
Abstract
Background and objectives: Kinetic façades represent a dynamic design approach that integrates movement to adapt to environmental conditions the concept of motion as a design input. One of the strategies of this facade is to control the light entering the interior. Fixed or dynamic horizontal shades are the best choice for south orientation, while vertical shades are usually used in east and west directions. Studies have shown that horizontal shading is more efficient than vertical shading. Indoor lighting conditions can affect the occupants’ visual comfort, satisfaction, thermal comfort, health, mood, motivation, performance, and productivity. Literature indicates that geometric and movement models play a role in controlling daylight and glare, although less attention has been given to movement axes in four directions. Also, it is unclear what kind of movement axis is appropriate for each façade direction. This research aims to utilize natural lighting using geometric models and rotational motion axes of the kinetic facade in the north, south, west, and east facades of an office building in Tehran. The novelty of this article is in examining the motion axes of the kinetic facade in response to Tehran's climate. For this purpose, the rotational motion axes in three horizontal, vertical, and diagonal modes in four directions have been measured to create optimal light in the interior space. The selection of samples is based on constructed examples that have not been used in previous studies, and the focus of this research is more on rotation motion axes and two geometric models, circle and rectangle.
Methods:This study utilises an applied, quantitative research methodology and is quantitative in nature. Using the simulation tool, the rotational motion axes of the kinetic facade are analyzed and evaluated in four directions, considering both circular and rectangular geometric models, and in relation to daylight in an office building in Tehran. Rhino software version 6.32, Grasshopper plugin and Honeybee Plus plugin version 0.0.06, and Ladybug version 1.5.0 were used for simulation. The Python programming language has also been used to calculate averages. The first step is to simulate the movement of the sun with the Ladybug plugin according to the weather file of Tehran. In the next step, a sample office room with an open plan, measuring 4 m in width, 6 m in length, and 3 m in height, accommodating six employees, was evaluated according to the dynamic daylight indicators. The room had a window-to-wall ratio of 90% of the facade without shades. In the next step, the existing two geometric modes of the kinetic facade, circle and rectangle, have been measured and compared according to the rotational movement axes (horizontal, vertical, and diagonal) in four facade directions. Then, according to the responsiveness of the facade to natural lighting, the most optimal geometric model and movement axes based on angle and dimensions (length, width, and radius) are suggested for all four directions of an office building in Tehran.
Results and conclusion :Recent research on kinetic facades in Iran and around the world indicates that kinetic facades are more responsive than fixed types in reducing glare and controlling daylight. Among them, geometric models, kinematic modes, movement axes, geometric model dimensions, room dimensions, the opening and closing angle of the geometric model of the facade in relation to the location of the sun, and the climate of the region play a significant role in optimising natural lighting in the interior space. According to the glare index (ASE) findings, the north facade does not require a shade, as the interior space receives sufficient daylight without one. Therefore, natural lighting simulation analysis with a kinetic facade has been done only for three directions of the south, east, and west facades. According to the simulation results, the two indicators, ASE and UDI, are of special importance. This is because when the shade opening or angle is half-closed, less light enters the space. As the percentage of useful light index decreases below 500 lux, the interior space may receive less than 500 lux of useful daylight at its far end.
Additionally, when the aperture or angle of view is open, more light enters the interior space and the amount of glare (ASE) shows values above 10%, which means that indoor glare and visual discomfort may occur. Therefore, optimising these two indicators is necessary to receive useful daylight in the interior. In the next step, the values of the two indices ASE, UDI less and DGP were averaged using the Python programming language. The simulation results show that the geometrical models of rectangle and circle with a rotating movement model with the horizontal axis at the top in the south, west, and east walls and with the diagonal axis at the top, both geometrical models in the east and west facade of an office building in Tehran are appropriate for providing optimal dynamic daylight indices. After comparing the geometric models based on the ASE and UDI indices in three directions, it is evident that the rectangular geometric model with a rotating movement model on horizontal and diagonal axes outperforms the circle geometric model with a rotating movement model on horizontal and diagonal axes. Also, the most suitable rotational motion axes of the kinetic facade for the two western and eastern facades are the horizontal and diagonal axis at the top and for the southern facade the horizontal axis at the top. Among the limitations of this research is the lack of an office building built with a kinetic facade in the field, so that a comparison can be made between the simulated results and field measurements.
On the other hand, natural lighting measurement devices in the indoor environment have limitations and cannot simultaneously measure the amount of daylight and glare in the indoor environment. In future research, it is possible to evaluate the kinetic facade with a rectangular geometric model and rotational movement model with horizontal and diagonal axes in four directions of the facade based on the amount of energy consumption, visual comfort, and thermal comfort using simulation or field observations. Furthermore, this facade can be studied in different climates and cities to determine its use with a geometric model and a proportional movement model in each city, according to the internal daylight. The results of this research can be applied to similar climates outside of Iran.
Keywords
Subjects

BS EN-12464-1. Light and lighting. Lighting of work places Indoor work places. BSI standards, (2021).
Anselm, Akubue Jideofor. ‘Passive annual heat storage principles in earth sheltered housing, a supplementary energy saving system in residential housing.’ Energy and Buildings 40, no. 7 (2008): 1214-1219.
Bahdad, Ali Ahmed, Nooriati Taib, Fahad Saud Allahaim, and Ali Mohammed Ajlan. ‘Parametric optimisation approach to evaluate dynamic shading within Double-Skin insulated glazed units for Multi-Criteria daylighting performance in tropics.’ Journal of Daylighting 11, no. 2 (2024): 349-371.
Compilation and promotion of national building regulations. Iran’s national building regulations, topic 13, design and implementation of electrical installations of buildings. Tehran: Iran Development Publishing House, (2015). (In Persian).
Elghazi, Y., Ayman Wagdy, Sahar Mohamed, and Asmaa Hassan. ‘Daylighting driven design: optimising kaleidocycle facade for hot arid climate.’ In Aachen: Fifth German-Austrian IBPSA Conference, RWTH Aachen University, pp. 314-321. 2014.Elghazi, Yomna, Ayman Wagdy, and Sahar Abdalwahab. ‘SIMULATION DRIVEN DESIGN FOR KINETIC SYSTEM; OPTIMISE KALEIDOCYCLE FAÇADE CONFIGURATION FOR DAYLIGHTING ADEQUACY IN HOT ARID CLIMATES.’ 14th Conference of International Building Performance Simulation Association, Hyderabad, India ,(2015):7-9. ‘https://doi.org/10.26868/25222708.2015.2705’
Erlendsson, Örn. ‘Daylight optimisation: A parametric study of atrium design.’ Master Science’s Thesis, Royal Institute of Technology, Stockholm, Sweden (2014).
Fakhari, Maryam, Rima Fayaz, and Maryam Mehravar. ‘The acceptable illumination level for office occupants in Tehran.’ Journal of Iranian Architecture & Urbanism (JIAU) 12, no. 1 (2021): 79-92.
Hassan, Fayrouz HF, Khaled AY Ali, and Salwa AM Ahmed. ‘Biomimicry as an approach to improve daylighting performance in office buildings in Assiut City, Egypt.’ Journal of Daylighting 10, no. 1 (2023): 1-16..
Hosseini, Seyedeh Nazli, SM Morteza Hosseini, and Milad HeiraniPour. ‘The role of Orosi’s Islamic geometric patterns in the building facade design for improving occupants’ daylight performance.’ Journal of Daylighting 7, no. 2 (2020): 201-221.Hosseini, Seyed Morteza, Masi Mohammadi, and Olivia Guerra-Santin. ‘Interactive kinetic façade: Improving visual comfort based on dynamic daylight and occupant’s positions by 2D and 3D shape changes.’ Building and Environment,no 165(2019): 106396. www.elsevier.com/locate/buildenv.
Ibrahim, JAAFAR AHMAD, and HALIL ZAFER Alibaba. ‘Kinetic facade as a tool for energy efficiency.’ Int. J. Eng. Res. Rev 7 (2019): 1-7.
Katabaro, Justine, and Yan Yonghong .‘Effects of Lighting Quality on Working Efficiency of Workers in Office Building in Tanzania.’ Journal of Environmental and Public Health,(2019): 1-12.
Kızılo¨renli, Ecenur, and Feray Maden. ‘Modular responsive facade proposals based on semi-regular and demi-regular tessellation: daylighting and visual comfort.’ Frontiers of Architectural Research.2023. doi:DOI:10.1016/j.foar.2023.02.005.
Kontovourkis, O, A Michael, K Alexandrou, and C Vassiliades. ‘Lighting performance simulation and adaptive control of an advanced building skin based on human behaviour inputs.’ 10th International Conference On Advanced Building Skins, Bern Switzerland,(2015): 1340-1349.
Kasmaei, Morteza. ‘Climate and architecture.’ Tehran: Khak Publishing (2003).
Li, Y. U. A. N. Y. U. A. N., C. H. E. N. Y. U. Huang, G. E. N. G. J. I. A. Zhang, and J. I. A. W. E. I. Yao. ‘Machine learning modeling and genetic optimisation of adaptive building facade towards the light environment.’ In Proc., 27th Int. Conf. of the Association for ComputerAided Architectural Design Research in Asia, (2022): 150-141.
LM-83-12, IES. Approved Method: IES Spatial Daylight Autonomy (sDA) and Annual Sunlight Exposure (ASE). North America: the Illuminating Engineering Society (2012).
Mahmoud, Ayman Hassaan Ahmed, and Yomna Elghazi. ‘Parametric-based designs for kinetic facades to optimise daylight performance: Comparing rotation and translation kinetic motion for hexagonal facade patterns.’ Solar Energy 126 (2016): 111-127.Nabil, A., and J. Mardaljevic. ‘Useful daylight illuminances: A replacement for daylight factors.’ Energy Build.no 38,(2006): 905–913.
Office of National Building Regulations. Energy saving / Topic 19. Tehran: Iran Development Publishing House, (1401).
Pourahmadi, Mahbubeh, Mohamadi Mohammad Ali Khan, and Farhang Mozaffar. ‘An Analytical Study on the Effect of envelope’s physical parameters on the Visual Comfort of Traditional housing in hot and Dry Climate of Iran (Case Study: five-door rooms in Yazd Traditional Houses).’ (2021): 135-153.Qiyabaklo, Zahra. ‘Fundamentals of construction physics 4 (passive cooling)’. Tehran: Jihad University, Amirkabir Industrial Unit, (2012). (In Persian).
Rasuli, M., Y. Shahbazi, and M. R. Matini. ‘Horizontal and vertical movable drop-down shades performance in double skin façade of office buildings; Evaluation and parametric simulation.’ Naqshejahan-Basic Studies and New Technologies of Architecture and Planning 9, no. 2 (2019): 135-144.
Resolution of the Supreme Administrative Council ‘Organisation of the administrative spaces of the executive bodies of the country.’ Deputy for compilation, revision and publication of laws and regulations, (1390).
Sangtarash, Fataneh, Rima Fayaz, Niloufar Nikghadam, and Mohammad Reza Matini. ‘Optimal window area of a kinetic facade to provide daylight in an office building in Tehran.’ Space Ontol. Int. J 11 (2022): 61-75.
Sangtarash, Fataneh, Niloufar Nikghadam, Rima Fayaz, and Mohammad Reza Matini. ‘A comparative study of the kinetic movement pattern of a triangular geometric facade regarding natural lighting in an office building in Tehran.’ Journal of Iranian Architecture & Urbanism (JIAU) 14, no. 2 (2023): 159-175.
Sangtarash, Fataneh, Niloufar Nikghadam, Rima Fayaz, and Mohammad Reza Matini. ‘A comparative study of the kinetic movement pattern of a triangular geometric facade regarding natural lighting in an office building in Tehran.’ Journal of Iranian Architecture & Urbanism (JIAU) 14, no. 2 (2023): 159-175. Sangtarash et.al. Utilising Kinematic Models of Kinetic Facades to Obtain Optimal Natural Lighting in an Office Building. J. Archit. Eng., 2025, 31(1): 04024050. DOI: 10.1061/JAEIED.AEENG-1705.
Samadi, Sahba, Esmatullah Noorzai, Liliana O. Beltrán, and Saman Abbasi. ‘A computational approach for achieving optimum daylight inside buildings through automated kinetic shading systems.’ Frontiers of Architectural Research 9, no. 2 (2020): 335-349.
Schumacher, Michael, Michael Marcus, Vogt Luis A, and Cordón Krumme. Architektur in Bewegung – Neue dynamische Komponenten und Bauteile. German: Birkhäuser.2019.
Sharaidin, Kamil. Kinetic facades: towards design for environmental performance. Environmental Science, Engineering RMIT University: Thesis Doctor of Philosophy (PhD). (2014).
Suk, J. Y., Schiler, M., & Kensek, K. ‘Investigation of existing discomfort glare indices using human subject study data.’ Building and Environment,Sol Energy,no78,(2016): 15–28.
Sureshkumar Jayakumari, Sujan Dev, Samarasinghalage Tharushi Imalka, Rebecca Jing Yang, Chengyang Liu, Siliang Yang, Max Marschall, Pablo Sepulveda Corradini, Adolfo Fernandez Benito, and Nick Williams. ‘Energy and daylighting performance of kinetic building-integrated photovoltaics (bipv) façade.’ Sustainability 16, no. 22 (2024): 9739..
Tabadkani, Amir, Masoud Valinejad Shoubi, Farzaneh Soflaei, and Saeed Banihashemi. ‘Integrated parametric design of adaptive facades for user’s visual comfort.’ Automation in Construction 106 (2019): 102857.
Veitch, Jennifer, Kelley Farley, and Guy Newsham. ‘Environmental Satisfaction in Open-plan Environments: 1. Scale Validation and Method.’ NRC/IRC Research Report IR-844, National Research Council Canada, Institute for Research in Construction, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada. (2002).
Zekraoui, Djamel, and Noureddine Zemmouri. ‘SMART AND DYNAMIC FACADES: A PATH TO ENERGY OPTIMIsATION IN ARID ENVIRONMENTS.’ journal of Architectural and Engineering Research, (2024): 84-102.
Zheng, Yiqian, Jinxuan Wu, Hao Zhang, Caifang Lin, Yu Li, Xue Cui, and Pengyuan Shen. ‘A novel sun-shading design for indoor visual comfort and energy saving in office space in Shenzhen.’ Energy and Buildings ,(2024):115083.
https://climate.onebuilding.org/WMO_Region_2_Asia/IRN_Iran/index.html.

  • Receive Date 24 August 2024
  • Revise Date 27 November 2024
  • Accept Date 10 December 2024